THE GREAT DR @ 11/10/2017 16:11

hot dogs arent sandwiches and neither are hoagies

The rest of the internet disagrees with your religious belief regarding hoagies:


http://www.google.com/search?q=hoagie+sandwiches&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8

they're all wrong

THE GREAT DR @ 11/10/2017 16:33

they're all wrong

Curtis says the majority is always right.

Rose, continue to be the flower growing in the crack in the pavement. Be different.

Bryce @ 11/10/2017 17:42

Rose, continue to be the flower growing in the crack in the pavement. Be different.

Rose is the lone weed burrowed beneath the pavement

Rose is the wind beneath my wings.

There are four scientists in this thread and fifteen climate deniers.

vladykins @ 11/10/2017 17:51

There are four scientists in this thread and fifteen climate deniers.

More like 4 goons who think the Earth is flat

Nah, we're not the ones clinging to a belief that a hot dog is different from the things just like it. ;)

Is a hamburger a sandwich?

Zersch @ 10/10/2017 23:05

Sorry for yelling I think I agreed with you there.

I was wondering why you were yelling exactly what I had just said lol

vladykins @ 11/10/2017 8:27

Christian @ 10/10/2017 21:31 it's called a hotdog, not a hotdog sandwich. End of discussion. A bacon, lettuce, and tomato, sandwich is called usually just called a BLT- it's become common parlance. In fact, someone would look at you strange if you said "I want a BLT sandwich." Does that mean a BLT is no longer a sandwich because its called a BLT? I see you all crawling to defend your weak arguments, with name-calling and trying to end the discussion. Like a religious person, you cling to your belief and can't accept that it isn't true. Come out of the cave and become a hot dog atheist. spin and I are waiting to accept you with open arms. Gay marriage and hot dogs as sandwiches are tough for a lot of people, but it is the right side of history.

A BLT is still a sandwich, a hotdog is not. :P

Christian @ 11/10/2017 17:00

vladykins @ 11/10/2017 8:27 Christian @ 10/10/2017 21:31 it's called a hotdog, not a hotdog sandwich. End of discussion. A bacon, lettuce, and tomato, sandwich is called usually just called a BLT- it's become common parlance. In fact, someone would look at you strange if you said "I want a BLT sandwich." Does that mean a BLT is no longer a sandwich because its called a BLT? I see you all crawling to defend your weak arguments, with name-calling and trying to end the discussion. Like a religious person, you cling to your belief and can't accept that it isn't true. Come out of the cave and become a hot dog atheist. spin and I are waiting to accept you with open arms. Gay marriage and hot dogs as sandwiches are tough for a lot of people, but it is the right side of history. A BLT is still a sandwich, a hotdog is not. :P

I have yet to have receive a single description for a hot dog that makes it not a sandwich that doesn't apply to something called a sandwich. I've received a lot of poor definitions that apply to other sandwiches, but nothing that sets a hot dog apart. Taxonomies don't work by "It feels different." I need observable characteristics that are different. Otherwise, all its characteristics match what I would call a "split-roll hot filling sandwich", which also includes meatball submarine sandwiches, italian sausage hoagie sandwiches, and philly cheesesteak sandwiches.

Maddie @ 11/10/2017 16:57

Is a hamburger a sandwich?

Well, based on Ben's poor definition, of course- two slices of bread with filling.

I would argue that it is a "sliced-roll hot filling sandwich".

it's a hotdog in a hotdog bun. That's what it's called. Nobody on earth ever asks for a hotdog sandwich, because it's not a sandwich. It's a hotdog, and will always be a hotdog.