Timmah @ 23/5/2017 13:36

17 of 21 have posted. Boc, Dr, TIB and nofo have no posts. Kiwi has 1. Helios has 2. Sock has 4, none of which have anything to do with helping town.

Brian is yet to post as well, and didn't post in yesterday's thread either.

ZacharyB @ 23/5/2017 12:47

Timmah @ 23/5/2017 13:40 Also, no one at all is talking about the fact that Angi claims she sent something to Primate N1 that was redirected or something. Has anyone else had something similar happen to them? I was about to ask about this. She said it was intercepted and thrown out and I find it weird that she knows that much detail about where her item went. Also it just seems weird since, like you said, we haven't heard about anything similar happen.

Intercepted and thrown out? What does that mean and how would the sender know any of that?

ZacharyB @ 23/5/2017 12:50

Timmah @ 23/5/2017 13:36 17 of 21 have posted. Boc, Dr, TIB and nofo have no posts. Kiwi has 1. Helios has 2. Sock has 4, none of which have anything to do with helping town. Brian is yet to post as well, and didn't post in yesterday's thread either.

oh I counted Jamie, so it's 16/21

Timmah @ 23/5/2017 12:39

What is the people blocked list? Lamps, Timmah, im317, miko? Anyone else? We have multiples claim it any night? What is the silenced list? ahoda (was he silenced? shows that mafia isn't afraid to silence their own), vlady, ???

I think it was last game that Ahora was silenced. This game, Vlady was silenced day 2 and me day 3. I'm thinking TIB might be silenced today

Timmah @ 23/5/2017 12:39

What is the people blocked list? Lamps, Timmah, im317, miko? Anyone else? We have multiples claim it any night? What is the silenced list? ahoda (was he silenced? shows that mafia isn't afraid to silence their own), vlady, ???

I was silenced N1 (D2).

ahoda posted yesterday, so he wasn't silenced. Nobody has indicated today they were silenced N2(D3), so we don't know who was the silent one yesterday.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 23/5/2017 12:57

Timmah @ 23/5/2017 12:39 What is the people blocked list? Lamps, Timmah, im317, miko? Anyone else? We have multiples claim it any night? What is the silenced list? ahoda (was he silenced? shows that mafia isn't afraid to silence their own), vlady, ??? I think it was last game that Ahora was silenced. This game, Vlady was silenced day 2 and me day 3. I'm thinking TIB might be silenced today

LOL- I stand corrected- we know who was silenced N2/D3 now. :)

Thanks badger. I guess I missed you saying this earlier?

Quick updated posting chart:

Member Name Number of Posts
Mercator 22
Timmah 20
Primate 18
ZacharyB 14
Angi 13
Hern 12
Maddie 9
vladykins 9
BadgerMcBeaver 8
Stephen 6
Josh 5
Miko 5
im317 4
Sock 4
Helios Garabandia 2
Kiwi 1
Boc 0
Dr 0
itsbrianyay 0
Nofo 0
thisisbad 0

Mercator @ 22/5/2017 23:15

BadgerMcBeaver @ 22/5/2017 22:06 Alright, just caught myself up, including yesterday's threads. Here are some of my thoughts: - I have no idea why the discussion about Mitten's Night 1 action was so heavily discussed in day 2. I got the impression it was a few townies getting sidetrack and tunneling on the subject, but there could be more to it. Scum could have been perpetuating it because for the most part, it was pretty pointless. But I do think there is some validity to the line of thought that mafia would probably be aware of the fact that Mittens was telling the truth and decided to try and gain town cred by defending him. - Not seeing why people are rushing to call Merc scummy this game. To me it looks like he's actively scum hunting. This is the towniest read I think I've ever had on him. - I think I believe Angi's claim, but interested to hear what Tib has to say about it. - Herm feels scummy to me this game. That's true of almost every game, but I'm still going to make note of it. - Brian and Rose have barely posted at all. Wouldn't mind seeing some pressure on them soon. Especially Brian, because he tends to show up when he's in danger. - Unsure what to make of the Zach thing, but I think I'm leaning towards believing the Day thread message at the moment? Nothing he's doing seems particularly scummy, but it's too significant of a lead to ignore. Point 1 and 2 tie together, TIB and a few others were trying to go for town cred and trying to lynch me at the same time, fairly obvious since he seems to refuse to acknowledge what I was saying about Mittens, repeatedly.

The thing about that is that you were 100% wrong about the DS role. The role doesn't read the way you said it did at all. Assuming an unstoppable would be announced would require you to assume they would also be stopped. It doesn't matter how loud or repetitive you are about that, you still read that role wrong in every possible way.

I can't speak for TIB, but I think you look scummy for that. A townie, who is not DS would likely be able to admit they were wrong instead of attacking those who read the role correctly.

Mercator @ 22/5/2017 23:15

BadgerMcBeaver @ 22/5/2017 22:06 Alright, just caught myself up, including yesterday's threads. Here are some of my thoughts: - I have no idea why the discussion about Mitten's Night 1 action was so heavily discussed in day 2. I got the impression it was a few townies getting sidetrack and tunneling on the subject, but there could be more to it. Scum could have been perpetuating it because for the most part, it was pretty pointless. But I do think there is some validity to the line of thought that mafia would probably be aware of the fact that Mittens was telling the truth and decided to try and gain town cred by defending him. - Not seeing why people are rushing to call Merc scummy this game. To me it looks like he's actively scum hunting. This is the towniest read I think I've ever had on him. - I think I believe Angi's claim, but interested to hear what Tib has to say about it. - Herm feels scummy to me this game. That's true of almost every game, but I'm still going to make note of it. - Brian and Rose have barely posted at all. Wouldn't mind seeing some pressure on them soon. Especially Brian, because he tends to show up when he's in danger. - Unsure what to make of the Zach thing, but I think I'm leaning towards believing the Day thread message at the moment? Nothing he's doing seems particularly scummy, but it's too significant of a lead to ignore. Point 1 and 2 tie together, TIB and a few others were trying to go for town cred and trying to lynch me at the same time, fairly obvious since he seems to refuse to acknowledge what I was saying about Mittens, repeatedly.

Miko @ 22/5/2017 23:52

Who's been the most vocal Merc-hater this game you guys believe? I have a theory on how to approach this lynch but I just need that info real quick. I'm looking back at the other days and so on and at specific people's posts - but your guys' help would work as well!

It's 100% me.

Sock @ 23/5/2017 2:51

Primate are you town?

Yes

If Angi sent me something N1, I wouldn't have received it.

That doesn't mean she couldn't be mafia, though.

if scum wants to lynch me, I ask that they do it now so I can defend myself instead of EOD when I am almost never around.

Primate @ 23/5/2017 13:20

If Angi sent me something N1, I wouldn't have received it.

Did I miss when Angi claimed?

Helios Garabandia @ 23/5/2017 13:30

Primate @ 23/5/2017 13:20 If Angi sent me something N1, I wouldn't have received it. Did I miss when Angi claimed?

She has said it a few times and specifically said who she sent stuff to. It's a softclaim- she hasn't said her role itself, only her actions.