Darren Sanders @ 2/5/2017 23:56

BadgerMcBeaver @ 2/5/2017 20:20 Darren Sanders @ 2/5/2017 23:14 Im leaning toward a Zach lynch unless he wants to claim vig. Is there a single role on the planet that you think is better left unclaimed? Cop & Doc Those are the only ones I can think of. Anything else clears up things for town more than it hurts imo. Though most people seem to think differently.

What about factionless backup? ;)

Sock's ability was able to succesfully target Timmah night 1. I'm not sure what a Nexus is though, never heard of that role before.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 2/5/2017 23:57

Alright, so from a numbers perspective, we had 29 people in the beginning of this game. We've hit three original mafia, one Third Party turned mafia, Two Third Party Serial Killers - six threats to town. Makes me think we are either looking for 3 or 4 more scum? Does that sound right to people?

Numbers look about right to me. I tend to have 25-30% scum in games I run, which would be in the 8-9 range. Although, I would probably count vlady as a half, and Buffy+im317 as one bad guy (only 1 kill action between them).

I can acknowledge it's still within the realm of possibilities that Zach could be mafia. But if he is, he is doing an absolutely incredible job for his first game.

He is giving me very strong town vibes. I'm not sure what other people are picking up on.

spindoctor02 @ 3/5/2017 0:08

BadgerMcBeaver @ 2/5/2017 23:57 Alright, so from a numbers perspective, we had 29 people in the beginning of this game. We've hit three original mafia, one Third Party turned mafia, Two Third Party Serial Killers - six threats to town. Makes me think we are either looking for 3 or 4 more scum? Does that sound right to people? Numbers look about right to me. I tend to have 25-30% scum in games I run, which would be in the 8-9 range. Although, I would probably count vlady as a half, and Buffy+im317 as one bad guy (only 1 kill action between them).

I think I'd count Buffy and im317 as two. Because if one of them dies, the third party killing still goes on. It just so happened that they died on the same day.

BadgerMcBeaver @ 2/5/2017 21:08

I can acknowledge it's still within the realm of possibilities that Zach could be mafia. But if he is, he is doing an absolutely incredible job for his first game. He is giving me very strong town vibes. I'm not sure what other people are picking up on.

Ive thought he was scummy all game but it could just be that he is new. The only information he has given us was off of an item if I remember correctly.

I think if he is vig then we are just dealing with Cherry 2.0

Today we should focus on the unclaimed imo.

Darren Sanders @ 3/5/2017 0:19

Today we should focus on the unclaimed imo.

If there is ever some sort of FE year book, I am signing this exact quote on the front of it. <3

Does anyone else find it odd that there would be a Suspect in a game with a Town Role Cop? Role cops tend to get fairly complete descriptions of the role.

DS my man you have the tunnel goggles on me very tight and I think if you took them off and thought for a second, we wouldn't be having this conversation at all.

I'm still interested in lynching Timmah today honestly.

Is Merc always this quiet?

ZacharyB @ 2/5/2017 21:27

DS my man you have the tunnel goggles on me very tight and I think if you took them off and thought for a second, we wouldn't be having this conversation at all.

You havent hinted at all about your role, and I know because I looked through all your posts before blocking you last night, so this just comes off even more scummy

ZacharyB @ 2/5/2017 21:30

I'm still interested in lynching Timmah today honestly. Is Merc always this quiet?

Im never against a Timmah lynch

and yes.

DS. Is Farlig's claim seriously giving you no pause? You were a large part of the reason I didn't shoot him before, but the claim's pretty sketch.

Also Zach, you were blocked on a night when there was a kill missing and you are being very dismissive of that. As I see it there are a few possible scenarios:

1) You were meant to kill someone and you didnt get the kill in because you were blocked
2) Herm isnt the doctor and he was meant to kill someone (though there has been no doc cc) but he didnt and he also is claiming to be blocked by mafia
3) Both the Vig and the Mafia attacked sock last night
4) ???