Herm @ 28/4/2016 13:31

Why couldn't it be SK/Mafia attacks? Anyway, Lamps you should claim. If you're town that is. If you're scum then that's not necessary.

Wrong. If I'm town it's not necessary. I don't see why I would claim when it looks like I was attacked by scum. All of y'all have a higher chance at being scum than myself, so I shouldn't be the lynch in the first place. All you accomplish by lynching me is help scum lynch their intended target.

Metagaming is my favorite part of mafia.

Im 100% sure Vlady and Timmah are scum. They were last game so they must be now as well.

LOL lamps is so fucking scummy.

Hop aboard, everyone. The train is about to leave the station! CHOO CHOO

vladykins @ 28/4/2016 9:26

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 8:40 I don't understand why a Vig couldn't have killed JC. Usually someone with that role can't resist killing someone. On the first few nights, in the absence of a solid scum read, they'll kill an inactive. But how about a player actively complaining about their role? Being distracting? And even self-voting at one point? I can see a Vig killing him. FOS on those that are discounting that. So you are saying that this game has a mafia who targeted Lamps and a vig that targeted JC and that we either have no SK or an SK who didn't bother to turn in a night action? I'm sorry, but that set up just sounds off to me. The fact that everyone is assuming vig, with *NO FLAVOR* at all to back that up seems silly and a way to give Lamps an out. I'm not sure where Curtis is suddenly saying people are framing him either, because outside of one post that I thought was a joke, nobody has even mentioned him. That strikes me as weirdly defensive.

I was catching up and remember seeing like three people talk about Mafia killing JC to frame me (they weren't joking). Just seemed like a silly line of thinking, I feel like that sorta framing is never successful

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 9:27

Herm @ 28/4/2016 13:31 Why couldn't it be SK/Mafia attacks? Anyway, Lamps you should claim. If you're town that is. If you're scum then that's not necessary. Wrong. If I'm town it's not necessary. I don't see why I would claim when it looks like I was attacked by scum. All of y'all have a higher chance at being scum than myself, so I shouldn't be the lynch in the first place. All you accomplish by lynching me is help scum lynch their intended target.

Maybe it's necessary because you are about to be lynched though.


It would also be nice to play this game without hearing about all the other games, but that's a lost cause.

Eben Etzebeth @ 28/4/2016 11:28

LOL lamps is so fucking scummy. Hop aboard, everyone. The train is about to leave the station! CHOO CHOO

He's already got 8 votes. How many more does he need this early? You and Vlady. smdh

thisisbad @ 28/4/2016 11:31

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 9:27 Herm @ 28/4/2016 13:31 Why couldn't it be SK/Mafia attacks? Anyway, Lamps you should claim. If you're town that is. If you're scum then that's not necessary. Wrong. If I'm town it's not necessary. I don't see why I would claim when it looks like I was attacked by scum. All of y'all have a higher chance at being scum than myself, so I shouldn't be the lynch in the first place. All you accomplish by lynching me is help scum lynch their intended target. Maybe it's necessary because you are about to be lynched though. It would also be nice to play this game without hearing about all the other games, but that's a lost cause.

Vlady is lost without playing flavor. His next line of game play is meta. ;)

Lamps relying on the idea that Mafia probably attacked him doesn't sit too well with me really. Seems like you're focusing too hard on that. I think it's worth claiming

Eben Etzebeth @ 28/4/2016 10:27

Curtis/Lamps connection noted.

I thought I was being so subtle :(

@Ahoda: I can appreciate keeping an open mind.

But what do you think now after seeing Lamps post with 8 votes on him?

Herm @ 28/4/2016 14:45

Lamps @ 28/4/2016 6:45 I feel like we've been here before. Pretty sure I was attacked by scum, so how exactly does that make me scum? JC looks like a vig target to me as for a vig it's hard to choose a target N1 and this is better for everyone. At least I would have killed him instantly if I had the chance. That would leave me as the mafia target. There's a lack of proper leads, and I got tons of votes already, so, ok. You don't think there's a SK in this game? Unless it's you?

Could be, what do I know? How is it relevant? Vlady came with the same flawed logic but I don't see what it proves if there is an SK. SK killed JC? Mafia attacked me? Or vice versa, but what does it prove. There is still a very low chance that I'm scum.

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 11:12

It seems cold hearted ... but if a Doc heals himself on N1 and gets hit ... his role is kind of ruined, no?

shhh dadd you lost your 'talking about the doctor' privileges




also in jay's defense, he was town when he was attacked!!!

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 11:34

@Ahoda: I can appreciate keeping an open mind. But what do you think now after seeing Lamps post with 8 votes on him?

That he doesn't need any more votes right now. He needs to explain better if possible. If he doesn't then he gets lynched. I have no idea what his alignment is.

Timmah @ 28/4/2016 15:14

Dadd @ 28/4/2016 9:11 Would like to hear more from Lamps. I can think of a few ways he could have survived, especially on a N1 And we can all think of several ways he could have survived as scum as well. I agree, he needs to put more of an explanation out there, if not claim outright. If he sticks with the tactic he already used of just calling people out for being stupid and scummy for voting him, then I'm going to lynch him.

Quote me.

@Lamps - How do you even begin to handicap the chance that you are scum? How do you figure that? Because you are assuming it's unlikely that scum targeted JC? That is the weakest argument I have ever heard.