Angi @ 20/1/2016 17:22

Ari @ 20/1/2016 10:41 I am also a bit worried on Angi´s claim just because its so very easy to fake. Not that it proves anything but ive seen a lot of filler posts from her and in most of her analyzing posts it doesnt seem to feature any definitive attacks. Just a bunch of maybes. Would like to hear from her more about who she suspects and wants to lynch. I gave my views yesterday Curtis @ 20/1/2016 10:42 Can't we tell Angi to lynch someone (with no one else lynching her) and then see if her vote counts at the end of the day? (: Great idea. Herm........unlynch please

That was yesterday.

Opinions change.

As soon as Herm unlynches I will lynch and when Christian does the update you will see.
you can also look back to the day when I tried to lynch a second player.......my vote wasn't counted sonce I had forgotten that I couldn't do it. Day 2 I think

Ari @ 20/1/2016 11:25

Angi @ 20/1/2016 17:22 Ari @ 20/1/2016 10:41 I am also a bit worried on Angi´s claim just because its so very easy to fake. Not that it proves anything but ive seen a lot of filler posts from her and in most of her analyzing posts it doesnt seem to feature any definitive attacks. Just a bunch of maybes. Would like to hear from her more about who she suspects and wants to lynch. I gave my views yesterday Curtis @ 20/1/2016 10:42 Can't we tell Angi to lynch someone (with no one else lynching her) and then see if her vote counts at the end of the day? (: Great idea. Herm........unlynch please That was yesterday. Opinions change.

I'm on my phone but will try to look and see if my opinion has changed or not. I am all for a Brian lynch tho. Based on things said today. And maybe Vic

Timmah @ 20/1/2016 17:19

Ari @ 20/1/2016 9:43 Timmah @ 20/1/2016 16:40 Ari @ 20/1/2016 9:19 Scum tend to have opinions to lynch Town. Ive stated the reasons why I think the targets you picked today are town. So you havnt had 10 minutes over the past week to sit down and write who you suspect / dont suspect? Very busy man! We would learn some info about the people who want to lynch you and those who dont. Hold on, so based on your first sentence here, you basically are saying that your entire reason for thinking that I'm scum is because I am going after JC? Because on D2, I definitely went after Miko, who we know was not town. Continue reading. Mostly because you have been very much tunneling on JC. Maybe tell us who else you suspect and wouldnt mind lynching? I am not going to deny that I'm tunneling, but I am also not going to abandon my top scum read. Here is who I suspect right now: JC - obvs. Vic - from D2, even more if JC is scum, and he seems to be "trying hard" without getting pinned in a corner; but, really really from D2 after analyzing that Badger - from D2, though I don't recall a lot of the rest of his game Wikey - from D2, and general lurking Curtis - especially if JC is scum, but also because Dadd's final list of scum reads was : Curtis, im317, FC, Bryce - at least one of those is mafia (FC flipped town and Bryce has soft claimed, leaving only 2 candidates imo) im317 - see reasoning above from Dadd's "scum list" brian - general lurking Jay - lurking mostly until he was called out today

Im317 looks pretty solid after looking back on day 2. Lynched Miko on a very crucial moment. I would have expected him to try and save him if they where scum buddies.

Curtis maybe, but I am surprisingly getting a town read from him at the moment but he is definitively on the lower end of my towny list.

Herm (2/8) - Ahoda, Jayadamo
JC (2/8) - Timmah, im317
Curtis (1/8) - Vernon
Jayadamo (1/8) - Vic
Angi (1/8) - Herm

I do get the point about Vic some of you are making. His track record as of yet isnt very impressive.

However, when I re-read everyones posts from day 1 - 4 it seemed to me that Vic was genuniely trying to figure stuff out. Asking questions and getting people to talk.

* -------- meta -------- *

Scum Vic doesnt do that.

* -------- meta -------- *

Maybe Vic has started playing differently but I dont think he should be the target today.

Looked back now.......it was Day 2
I lynched Chris........unlynched and then lynched Rob.........you can see my name was not added to the Rob vote at all. That should confirm the second paet of my role.
but Herm unlynching me will prove the first part of my role

Ari, I think you are right about im317 likely not being mafia based on D2. Maybe Dadd didn't list any of his mafia buddies in his final "scum read list", but if he did list one then I think it's probably Curtis.

Typical behavior in that situation seems to be that a mafia member would list 3 non-mafia and slip one mafia buddy in there, but that may just be how I'm thinking I would operate.

## unlynch

Herm (2/8) - Ahoda, Jayadamo
JC (2/8) - Timmah, im317
Curtis (1/8) - Vernon
Jayadamo (1/8) - Vic
Angi (0/8) - Herm

## lynch Brian

Get to talking, he could just as well be scum as he could be town imo. If not him, then I would lynch any individual who came off as scummy during the D2 lynch train, be it Vic or Badger or Ahoda.

I guess what we need to figure out is how Dadd placing his lynch vote on Coral to save Miko, relates to everyone placing votes.

Anyone not placing votes during that whole period should be looked at as well.

Timmah @ 20/1/2016 10:33

Ari, I think you are right about im317 likely not being mafia based on D2. Maybe Dadd didn't list any of his mafia buddies in his final "scum read list", but if he did list one then I think it's probably Curtis. Typical behavior in that situation seems to be that a mafia member would list 3 non-mafia and slip one mafia buddy in there, but that may just be how I'm thinking I would operate.

If Bryce and 317 are Town...then he didn't list a scum buddy :)

I feel like my posts towards Dadd were pro-town. I was trying to push him to talk and slip like I usually do by asking him his suspects but he wouldn't give them at first. Kinda silly for me to push that and then have him put my name on the list if I were scum. I was adamant on D3 about wanting him lynched right after Miko

I'm guessing he listed all townies. He also seems like a newer player(?) so he might not have thought to throw scum buddies in the mix. Bryce and 317 do seem more townish to me after today

hey guys i just finished day 3

from that i think these people are town: ahoda, vic, timmah. they all seem to be actually trying to solve the game, asking good questions and making good observations.

not trying to beat a dead horse but i think that jc's explanation for killing nofo was really weak. it felt to me that he was trying to justify not killing miko by saying he submitted early against a troll player. which he may have submitted early but nofo wasn't really trolling this game, and i don't think i've ever seen him put legitimate effort in when he's scum. yes, he can be useless as town, but whenever he's contributing, i THINK he's always been town.

another person i'm looking at is badger. on the opposite side of the spectrum of ahoda/vic/timmah, badger's post that day was mostly a summary of other people's thoughts rather than an input of any of his own. the only thing that made me sway from this was his post about miko's bad vig claim since he was the first to say it directly contradicted with patrick's cop claim, buuuut it sorta seemed like no one was believing it so it could've just been a bus push to gain town cred. (this critique may be a bit ironic if people have already expressed this, but oh well, it's

i go back and forth on curtis a lot. some posts of his scream scum while others scream town and there's almost no middle ground, it's really weird. at this point, i'm undecided.

i almost put ari in the town pile but i'm not ready to yet, a few posts didn't feel quite right (but a majority of them did)

---------

again, this is just from day 3, i'll start reading day 4 now but i do actually have to get some work done so it may be a bit

"it's how i feel"* for that unfinished sentence

Question for Bryce. If you die and your role is flipped, will it be clear to us what information you had on Merc and Brian?

I was gonna suggest you go ahead and fully claim so we can see the Brian info before you potentially die and we never know, but if it'll be clear from your role flip then there's probably no need