spookyerrose @ 2/11/2015 15:32

CanuckStud @ 2/11/2015 18:03 So here's a question for the group that are buying the Rose/Nobert twins claim. At what point in the game that they stay alive do we take the chance and lynch them to see if they're telling the truth? Yes, to make that claim is a big risk, but if it scares town enough that they make it 3 or 4 days before town takes a chance, then it is definitely worth it. Also, I've seen situations like this where 1 is town and 1 is scum, so it is possible that 1 of them is town and 1 is scum, but they don't know each other's alignment, just that they're twins. Again, we have to lynch 1 of them to know for sure. No. We aren't one town, one mafia. We are both confirmed town to each other. Either we are both lying, or we are both town. There's no inbetween choice. It really feels like people are trying to sweeten the deal for lynching us. I don't like it!

Just checked back, Nobert did confirm they were both twins and town, so either they are both lying, or they are both telling the truth. There is still only 1 way to find out for sure, and that's for one of them to die.

So it is good to know that you only have to be active on d1, then you can skate by for 3 - 4 days before anyone actually remembers you're even playing, and at that point you get another few days before anyone wants to do anything about it.

I must say that I'm getting a scum vibe from Henry. I don't mind him wanting to lynch JC if he's got reason's in the game, such as not believing his claim. But to want to lynch him just because he's a "big cunt" seems pretty scummy.

Borrowing from your list, Herm:

Town:
Buffy: Town Roleblocker

Probably town:
Brian: Town Doctor - I guess if he's lying about being poisoned we'll find out, I tend to believe him
Rose/dr: Town Lover - Idk if Rose would risk this claim and drag in a fellow mafia member so I tend to believe her
Nobert: Town Lover - If Rose is town, so is Jeff, if scum, so is Jeff
im317: Town Vigilante (jumped on Vernon's train started by Angi Day 1, lynched JC Day 2) - I don't see him telling us he's Vig out of thin air. It would be quite crafty, I guess but he didn't have to claim when he did. He does tend to claim early as town.

Leaning town:
JC: ??? (was silenced Day 2) - I kinda believe he was silenced, if so that would be a mafia role - but could also be a con job
Wikey: ??? (big contributor) - idk nothing major stands out to point to him being scum yet

Unsure:
Herm: Don't know
Canuck: ??? (jumped on Vernon's train Day 1, lynched JC Day 2) - idk I had a bad vibe from him D2 but I have to go back and read to see why because I can't remember. Just unsure for now.
Curtis: ??? (started a lynch train on Primate Day 3, lynched Brian Day 1) - seems to be acting differently this game than the last few, could be more time available, idk.
Henry: ??? - who knows
Dyl: ??? - I actually had a vibe about Dylan just because he's very subtle and says just enough to plant seeds but doesn't take the initiative in lynching I think...
Ari: Town Firefighter - Claim could def be bogus and him saying he wasn't blocked could or could be a lie, I guess he would lie if he's scum but why not just say he was blocked and this is his role? Makes no sense unless just to discredit me? Risky, although there is always pointing to the unknown factors

Scum Vibes:
Timmah: ??? (big contributor, lynched JC Day 2) - I have bad vibes because all he does is talk about how the people who have claimed are liars (wants to lynch Rose for example), yet he has no qualms in thinking JC is telling the truth. Also, complains about the Primate lynch - could be to make himself look good while he lynches someone in the minority instead - then he can put the blame on everyone else.
Redster: ??? (was blocked by Buffy Night 1, was lynched by Buffy Day 2) - Lurker, doesn't post. I had bad vibes from him from the beginning.
Schrauben: ??? (low activity) - lurker scum
Jayadamo: ??? (low activity) - so far all he's done is lynch me from what I remember, after my claim I don't think he's posted at all


##lynch Timmah

I'm starting to think Schrauben is a good lynch for today unless a better alternative shows up.

I honestly don't think lynching an inactive is bad on Day 4 if we have no other solid leads but is there a better lynch that tells us more? Just lynching someone who has claimed to find out isn't good enough for me. If it tells us a LOT and outweighs the risk if they are being truthful, then that's one thing. But, why do Mafia's job for them if it seems more likely they are town than not?

schrauben Viewing Topic Day 3 One minute ago

I think this is right, correct anything that's wrong.

Schrauben (2/9) - Ari, Canuck
JC (2/9) - Buffy, Henry, Wikey
Ari (1/9) - Timmah, Curtis
Redster (0/9) - Canuck
Timmah (1/9) - Buffy

Not voted: Brian, Rose, Schrauben, Dylan, JC, im317, Jay, Redster, Herm, Nobert (Jeff)

Not posted today: Schrauben, Redster, im317, Jay

2 hours left - deadline 10:30pm EST

If nothing changes I'd switch to Schrauben.

not caught up yet, sorry forgot the game started again last night.

i didn't kill anyone night 1 and i did kill Chris last night. my bad, i wanted to remove an inactive so we didn't have that as a cop out lynch option.

##lynch Ari, based on Buffy's claimed block target

Hahahahahah

So I'm scummy for finding it ridiculous that we seem to be missing a mafia kill 2 straight nights and both of the following days the person who was blocked isn't going to be the lynch. 2 games ago Buffy blocked me on a night where there "appeared" to be no kill and every fucking one of you pissed yourselves in excitement to lynch me.

But not this time.

So here we go again. For the second straight day we have what has been presented as solid info, and no one wants to even check it out. Bravo people!

I think Wikey unlynched.

im317 @ 2/11/2015 20:43

not caught up yet, sorry forgot the game started again last night. i didn't kill anyone night 1 and i did kill Chris last night. my bad, i wanted to remove an inactive so we didn't have that as a cop out lynch option. ##lynch Ari, based on Buffy's claimed block target

Yet here they are trying to lynch an inactive anyway

Well, now that im317 has confirmed the Chris kill (which does seem Vigish imo) I am considering lynching Ari. I guess just saying he knows he wasn't blocked adds to confusion that he could be town IF people buy it. Also, the claim seems convenient.

Someone should tell him he is viewing the wrong thread!

There isn't much time left, we need to decide on someone and do so quickly. Can't see the Timmah lynch. Don't think he has done anything particularly scummy, and we'd stand to lose an active contributor. Also, he hasn't disputed the claims anywhere near as much as Canuck and JC. In fact he seems to be leaning towards believing most of them.

At the other end of the spectrum, Schrauben is completely inactive...lynching him is a shot in the dark.

Canuck is worth considering. He has echoed a lot of the thoughts that made me suspect JC.

##Lynch Canuck