With all these claims not lining up, what do we gain by lynching Primate? Wouldn't we get more information lynching one of im317, rose, or buffy?

spookyerrose @ 31/10/2015 22:19

so why would I take that risk of him lying?

*that risk of him calling me out on lying

JC @ 31/10/2015 22:21

With all these claims not lining up, what do we gain by lynching Primate? Wouldn't we get more information lynching one of im317, rose, or buffy?

We would also be potentially losing 2 townies, a town roleblocker, or the vigilante.

JC @ 31/10/2015 22:21

With all these claims not lining up, what do we gain by lynching Primate? Wouldn't we get more information lynching one of im317, rose, or buffy?

What doesn't line up?

spookyerrose @ 31/10/2015 21:22

JC @ 31/10/2015 22:21 With all these claims not lining up, what do we gain by lynching Primate? Wouldn't we get more information lynching one of im317, rose, or buffy? We would also be potentially losing 2 townies, a town roleblocker, or the vigilante.

We are always potentially losing townies. Well, unless someone is going to claim to be scum.

If the odds are that we are losing a townie, wouldn't we want to lose one that provides the most information? I just don't see what we gain by lynching Primate?

Explain "don't line up" because I see no proof of that comment.

While I think we learn more by lynching im317 or rose, we learn absolutely nothing by a no-lynch.

## Lynch Primate

Faked being silenced? ^^^ Possible.

The unlikeliness of all 3 of those claims lining up is very low.

im317 claims vig - killing ahoda
buffy claims roleblocker - block rose
rose claims town lover (with norbert) - doesn't know if blocked or not.

With only 1 kill, either we had another person with a save, the mafia chose to no kill on N2, or one of you is lying.

The last option is most likely, imo.

Past deadline, stop posting.

Buffy @ 31/10/2015 21:30

Faked being silenced? ^^^ Possible.

Yep, the heat was so hot on me I made up being silenced.

/sarcasm

Buffy @ 31/10/2015 21:31

Past deadline, stop posting.

You stop posting then too. :P

Thread isn't locked, and there is nothing in the rules saying we can't post in an open thread.

Or someone else was blocked. Or the off chance shot of both Mafia and Vig killing Ahoda or Mafia kill being redirected to Ahoda or some shit

I can buy Rose lying but I'd also like to see if Jeff shows up tomorrow to confirm

JC @ 31/10/2015 22:33

Buffy @ 31/10/2015 21:31 Past deadline, stop posting. You stop posting then too. :P Thread isn't locked, and there is nothing in the rules saying we can't post in an open thread.

Locked :)

JC @ 31/10/2015 22:32

Buffy @ 31/10/2015 21:30 Faked being silenced? ^^^ Possible. Yep, the heat was so hot on me I made up being silenced. /sarcasm

I'm word filtering the "/sarcasm" line that 'you people' from 'your board' seem to think is so great!