Are you allowed to kill tonight? Otherwise I can boost someone else's role I guess.

Matt @ 11/10/2013 21:49

Are you allowed to kill tonight? Otherwise I can boost someone else's role I guess.

nope, I can't

o hai Justin

Paco @ 11/10/2013 21:30

Also....I don't remember animal posting much the past few days. Possible scum trying to stay low since all his buddies are dead?

So fR trying to catch up but I'm not hme and mobile and out so likely won't catch up soon but will keep sneaking reads

I didn't get home yesterday until after you fus already hammered DD though but I think I have we. Active mostly of the tkmes

Paco @ 11/10/2013 22:08

Going back to Animal for a second I just checked quickly and the only day he didn't post was yesterday. But I'llchalk that up to lynching DD rather quickly and ending the day after something like 6 or 7 hours. Would still like to hear his thoughts anyway!

Oh thanks lo9l!

Okay I read a little and I didn't understand it all but the ff/samm thing is weird? I don't get it though loool and I always had FOS on Matt but apparently you guys feel you know his role and stuff but I'm just a newb and have no idea

Sorry I haven't posted much recently I've been busy until late at night so I will be back when I get home!!!

IN LIGHT OF NEWER INFORMATION

Town
Ari
Boc
Lamps
Paco
Patrick

Probably Town?
Matt

On the Fence
ff_zero

Possible SK
Bryce
Justin
Korr
Samm
Wikey
Animal

Possible Mafia
Justin
Samm


I've said before that I think all of Bryce, Korr, and Animal's actions this game have been very town-like, so I don't see them as scum. They're all SK candidates though since we don't know anything about their roles. And if Wikey is anything he's probably SK, because I don't think anything he's done is suspicious besides POSSIBLY deflecting attention off of Mal by suggesting going for Vic instead, which would point to being SK, not mafia.

So that just leaves Justin and Samm for me as mafia candidates. While I don't think anything Justin's said or done has been overtly scummy, he hasn't really done much at all so it's hard to say either way (:

So right now I'm leaning towards a Justin lynch just because I can see him being SK OR the last mafia.

But I don't think the whole FF/Samm discrepancy can be ignored either. It definitely seems like one of them is lying, and if one of them is I think it's Samm. The only way I can see it making sense is if Samm used his kill on one of the first 3 nights before it could be used on FF. But that'd require either a roleblocker or the mafia/SK/vig aiming for the same target. If there's a town roleblocker out there, you should definitely come forward now. Otherwise I GUESS it could've been Rob blocking the SK (since I know I didn't get blocked). It just seems all too coincidental though

ff_zero @ 11/10/2013 20:13

Read Mal's description... It says right in it that he scans as vanilla town.

The thing I'm trying to figure out is if you got Mal as town, why didn't you ever step up and say that? I know he survived an attack, but for all you know a doctor saved him. That doesn't add up for me and all the people you have scanned are people who are dead except Sam and Lamps which Lamps doesn't make sense why you would scan him honestly.

meh

##lynch Justin

The Samm/FF thing doesn't sit right with me but this is probably our safest bet for today. Especially after he didn't even bother to say anything earlier.

@Matt:

Maybe try boosting Lamps or FF's roles tonight? Both could be useful

##lynch: Justin

What does boosting mean? Did I miss that? lol

But I agree the Sam/FF thing doesn't sit right with me but for some reason, neither seem overtly sketchy? It's just an odd disagreeance, which makes no sense to lie unless you're trying to hide something, which in case would mean one is likely scummy/third party/something other than town. I just don't know much. I got a scummy vibe from Samm until he revealed and then I felt he was townie and ff hasn't been around to give me too much of an impression but when he is here, it seems he is townie?

##lynch Justin

ooops

##unlynch

##Lynch: Justin

I believe both Samm and ff, but yeah there's something weird about it for sure.

I don't believe Samm would role claim in the way he did if he were scum. Like posting on day 3 that you probably killed/almost killed one of them... that doesn't make a whole lot of sense to me. You'd have to be a very experienced player to fool everyone like that, so early in the game? Plus chances were there was another PGO in the game who would have had no reason to keep quiet.

I was on the fence about FF, but I don't see why he would vouch for Samm to be town if he were scum.

Could it be that 317 swapped two players that night and this is why Jen died and some other stuff happened? Idk probably doesn't make sense, but I believe Samm and FF for now.