Stargate can you refute the logic Shadow is presenting?

I proved I wasn’t mafia when I escaped

Also when I used my power to steal mittens vote and lynch him

If anything you should be saying I’m anti. That ship has sailed

Jackie @ 15/10/2020 19:42

Stargate can you refute the logic Shadow is presenting?

He can’t

It’ll be more paragraphs of nonsense.


I will be lynched by you and josh tomorrow easily. Why would I even fight it just to survive one round longer?

Jackie @ 15/10/2020 19:42

Stargate can you refute the logic Shadow is presenting?

Yes that post I made just there puts the nail in Shadow's coffin. Read her posts if not mine about why I have to be lynched here or Town loses. They make no sense given what my role is and has always been. Odd night bp, even night vig. Shadow is saying oh, maybe now he can inherit an extra kill wooo spooky. That's rediculous and based in nothing. Everything I posted is based in the logic of the situation.

I cannot kill tonight. There's no way Town can lose by lynching Shadow "first" since Shadow's lynch wins us the game. It ends there. But if you believe I am scum, then there's no real logic to not lynching Shadow first, right? Cause how can I kill tonight? I can't. But Shadow's own words about their role, says they take from the graveyard. I know that's a lie, but I only know that because they've taken my role this round. Which means they are scum. But if you choose to believe I'm lying and Shadow is telling the truth, then Shadow CAN take from the graveyard and can kill tonight using one of those graveyard roles. Right?

That's far more likely than me inheriting Zersch's power. Far more likely than there being 2 anti hero vig's, a sk, and no town vig's. Far more likely than there being three town aligned people who can role cop alignments and clear people as town.

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 19:44

Jackie @ 15/10/2020 19:42 Stargate can you refute the logic Shadow is presenting? He can’t It’ll be more paragraphs of nonsense. I will be lynched by you and josh tomorrow easily. Why would I even fight it just to survive one round longer?

The only way there is a tomorrow is if I'm lynched.

If he flips town, doesn’t that just confirm I took his role and therefore can’t use it tonight as it’s an odd night?? Lol

I would essentially be a sitting duck to be lynched next

Literally he has to be lynched.

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 19:50

If he flips town, doesn’t that just confirm I took his role and therefore can’t use it tonight as it’s an odd night?? Lol I would essentially be a sitting duck to be lynched next Literally he has to be lynched.

I pray you are just prolonging this to lose. But that seems so dumb to me and makes me feel way more confident in you having a way to kill tonight. Either as the last Mafia who didn't kill last night to conceal yourself and kill tonight for the win. Or unless your role gives you a kill that you failed to mention. For all we know you're an Anti-Hero JOAT type role. Anyway if you're not lynched after this then idk what to say:

Stargate @ 15/10/2020 19:41

Shadow, you're missing the point. I can't be Mafia. There is a chance you can be. And can kill tonight. And if I'm lying, which I'm not, about you stealing my role here, then you are saying you take someone's role from the graveyard. Therefore you CAN kill tonight. in their eyes. Only I know you took my role. And are lying about the graveyard part. But you slipped up in your post where you said nothing about a graveyard when you first claimed. You borrowed Mittens' vote. He knew that round it was gone and not his. I know this round you've borrowed my role. Either you legit can't win and are just prolonging this to get voted out on Day 10. Or you are Mafia and can kill tonight. Or there's another aspect to your role and can kill tonight. But if Jackie and Josh choose not to believe that you stole my role, then they are forced to believe you CAN take someone's role from the graveyard and use it to kill someone tonight. Like that's what they have to believe. Either you stole my role and are scum. Or you can take from the graveyard and can kill tonight. Whereas I cannot kill tonight. So the safest lynch is you, Shadow.

Your argument of saying there’s more to my role is no different than me saying the same if yours. Except I’ve proven my role twice now.


I forgot how mentally exhausting mafia was

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 19:57

Your argument of saying there’s more to my role is no different than me saying the same if yours. Except I’ve proven my role twice now. I forgot how mentally exhausting mafia was

You clearing someone as Town is not you being cleared as Town. You, as scum, know the three of us are Town.

Stargate @ 15/10/2020 20:00

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 19:57 Your argument of saying there’s more to my role is no different than me saying the same if yours. Except I’ve proven my role twice now. I forgot how mentally exhausting mafia was You clearing someone as Town is not you being cleared as Town. You, as scum, know the three of us are Town.

I’ve proven my role through my actions I mean. Also if I was anti I wouldn’t know if any of you were. I cleared Jackie ages ago.

Wish it’s been known you’re “vig” for rounds but you’re still alive? It’s all sus

I can not type on my phone sorry

Shadow @ 15/10/2020 20:02

Stargate @ 15/10/2020 20:00 Shadow @ 15/10/2020 19:57 Your argument of saying there’s more to my role is no different than me saying the same if yours. Except I’ve proven my role twice now. I forgot how mentally exhausting mafia was You clearing someone as Town is not you being cleared as Town. You, as scum, know the three of us are Town. I’ve proven my role through my actions I mean. Also if I was anti I wouldn’t know if any of you were. I cleared Jackie ages ago.

Farlig cleared Jackie.

I've cleared my role through my actions. I have never killed on an odd night. So like? Your role, as you are saying it is, has you able to take a role from the graveyard and use that ability to kill tonight/tomorrow. YOU ARE SAYING THIS. You are saying you haven't stolen my role and can take a role from the graveyard. What role are you going to take? Huh? I know you've stolen my role this round and are scum, but you've not told the others what role you're gonna take from the graveyard. Enlighten us.

In the end none of this matters. You are saying you can take a role from the graveyard, therefore by your logic you can kill tonight. I've never been able to and am not saying I can. You are literally saying you can take a role from the graveyard.

You and I know you've taken my role and are scum, but you are saying you take from the graveyard. x9000 times I'll repeat that. You have put yourself into a situation where you have the possibility to take a role from the graveyard and kill tonight. You've said this. I know you can't. But if the choice is to lynch me or you, there's no reason to think I can kill tonight. There is reason, from you, to think you can kill tonight.

I said I can use a town role - none can kill at night. You’re saying I took yours - therefore I can’t kill tonight. YOU fucked up.

Well I'm headed out for the night!