You don't say (:

Korr @ 21/2/2013 21:24

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 4:32 I wanna get the Korr thing straight a bit. It's confusing me for some reason Korr visited Drr night 1 to confirm that he's town. You can confirm it was him Drr obviously Korr visited Rob night 2 to confirm that he's town. Rob mentioned something about it I think? I remember there being discussion surrounding it Who'd you visit night 3 Korr? Dylan

I think you may of visited scum again lol.

Dylan @ 21/2/2013 2:22

My question is when Korr sent me the letter it said how we are both humans. I am not sure if I can copy and paste it or not but basically it was very robotic speech and involved how we were both humans. How would he know I was human. Is that involved in his role? Is that just his assumption. I feel like when he role claimed he left out a lot of details that would be helpful. Also does he chose what he says or just what his role is. I am very confused about that.

Nah you can't copy/paste

He wouldn't know that you're town. He picks who he thinks is town. The host sends that player a message from Korr (written by the host). So when you get the message you know for a fact that he's town, since it's host confirmed. A host confirmed message like that can't be wrong or that's very cruel

Since Korr's here he can maybe shed some light a bit

Kiwi what's your theory on Dylan? If you posted it earlier I missed it or forget it

Yea Mr. Kiwi

Why do you think he thunk wrong.

Dylan @ 21/2/2013 2:22

Curtis @ 21/2/2013 2:09 I think I get Dylan's Jeff/Mal/Cult theory If Jeff was the Cult Leader, and IF he had a one time BP, and IF his attack on night one was a result of him trying to recruit scum... then he wouldn't have gone after Mal to lynch the next day, who was town. He would have gone after the person that he attempted to recruit. It's a good theory but there's a few too many if's and there's also the possibility of a bus driver messing his target up Is that what you're saying Dylan? Yea the argument last round was that Jeff could of been the cult leader with one time bullet proof. I am saying that is probably not the case. My question is when Korr sent me the letter it said how we are both humans. I am not sure if I can copy and paste it or not but basically it was very robotic speech and involved how we were both humans. How would he know I was human. Is that involved in his role? Is that just his assumption. I feel like when he role claimed he left out a lot of details that would be helpful. Also does he chose what he says or just what his role is. I am very confused about that.

I don't think Korr actually types up the message. It's flavor. Mine was like "hello non-bot I am not a bot also" or something like that. But the confirmation from the host beneath it, that Korr is town, is why I'm trusting it. It's not a scan, it's a role where the friendly neighbor (Korr) informs a player every night that he is town. A scum role that made itself host-confirmed innocent would be incredibly overpowered.

I did doubt it a bit because one could also say a don becoming a third party ball of smoak is somewhat unbalanced, but the fact that Ublaz kept quiet about the message instead of using it to confirm a scummate indicates to me that Paul didn't decide to break the role.

Korr is town.

For once I am actually going to gather evidence. Its a rare day. Also Vernon thinks Dylan is scum and he has the best record known to mankind.

Kiwi @ 21/2/2013 2:31

For once I am actually going to gather evidence. Its a rare day. Also Vernon thinks Dylan is scum and he has the best record known to mankind.

Well thanks for starting your argument of by basically confirming my innocence. I read Curtis' argument against Wikey and I think it is strong and think there is a good case for Wikey.

LSF is basically useless and could be an inactive mafia member causing havoc. Then again he could not but he is not particularly useful for the town. Justin is getting there but he seems to post every round which is good.

Someone I am interested in is Shawn. This may just because he hasn't played a lot of these but every single one of his posts is about how no one else is posting. And while that is I guess good information it is something that everyone can deduce and might just be something he is doing because he doesn't want to seem inactive and useless like the previously mentioned LSF.

Ari was pretty strong on keeping Mal so I feel like in a way if he was scum he wouldn't of pushed that hard. It would be a lot easier if we knew what Jeff was.

Quote

Looool sucks to suck mafia! I don't think Mal did anything. Also rules Jeff out as the cult leader. Not sure how I feel about him. Ari pushing for Mal hard probably wasn't scummy because he did it really obviously. Kiwi is someone I'm curious about. I'm not convinced both Rose and Curtis are clean either.

- The first paragraph is kinda what Grim did. Not solid but a little suspicious as my boy Shawn pointed oou.
- I think Rose/Curtis are town and I am fairly confident I am too so pushing it in our direction is a little strange. Also odd you protect Ari for pushing hard for Mal but fail to mention Rose pushing hard for Grim too?

Quote

Someone I am interested in is Shawn. This may just because he hasn't played a lot of these but every single one of his posts is about how no one else is posting. And while that is I guess good information it is something that everyone can deduce and might just be something he is doing because he doesn't want to seem inactive and useless like the previously mentioned LSF.

Turning it on to someone I publicly thought was scummy? Scummy.

Quote

surviving a night attack is always fishy.

This post just seems odd to me. First this post and now your whole Jeff = Cult leader theory. I find the cult theory hard to believe, personally.

Quote

What do we think of Justin's greenday hate. I feel like he's not smart enough to do that to seem like not a mafia though who knows he might be some mafia pro. The Jeff argument seems pretty good. Would love to hear what the Bito is thinking. Also see who Rob can confirm/deny to being good or bad.

Subtly trying to protect Greenday? Justins "hate" for Greenday was this: "Oh thank god we're lynching greenday. I wanted this yesterday." Justin had lynched Greenday the previous day so it backs it up. (I think Justin is town too). The Jeff argument (Cult thing) is not "pretty good" its extremely unlikely as shown by Curtis's IF posts. Surely this game is too small for a cult too.

Also based on Justin being town:

Quote

Justin is getting there but he seems to post every round which is good.

You seem to be targeting Justin in my opinion based on several of your posts.

Quote

It also said that Korr is Town. Not sure how legit that is though.

Why is it not legit exactly?


Now the evidence is hardly overwhelming but I think it brings up some interesting points. Several people I believe to be town you seem to be casting suspicion on too. You also jumped on the Greenday when it looked certain he would go. Even when you lynched Greenday you put in a defence for him casting suspicion on Rob. And if you were scum you wouldn't know Rob is mafia.

And pointing out Shawn's posts about people who don't post is interesting as Curtis did it a lot yesterday when he was targeting Grim and you never said anything. Also you seem to take an issue with Justin/LSF for not posting much but Grim didn't and you didn't seem to mention her before today.

Wait so what is Koors role?

And why is he town

Curtis I called u today and u ignored my call. Sup with dat bro?

Kiwi @ 21/2/2013 2:53

- I think Rose/Curtis are town and I am fairly confident I am too

You aren't sure? So scummy...

ARI:

Day 1: Joke voted Drrr. Nothing more
Day 2: Wanted to vote Drrr or Mal. Said he understood the case against Greenday. Lynched Mal then Greenday after Rob spilled about Greenday
Day 3: Started off by lynching Mal. Started getting suspicious of Drrr. Defended Rito and later Jeff

DRR:

Day 1: Joke voted Justin and Korr. Lynched LSF for being inactive. Switched off of him to Panda after Panda's post
Day 2: Got mad at Rob
Day 3: Lynched Rito. Defended Jeff. Suspicious of Ari. Got mad at me for lynching Grim. Lynched me. Helped the last minute lynch from Jeff to Mal. Lynched Mal

DYLAN:

Day 1: Lynched Panda
Day 2: Joined Rob's lead and lynched Greenday
Day 3: Agreed with a Jeff lynch. Suspicious of Shawn and Drrr. Lynched Jeff. Defended Rito. Part of the last minute change to lynch Mal instead of Jeff. Lynched Mal

JUSTIN:
Day 1: Joke lynched Greenday
Day 2: Joined the train late and lynched Greenday
Day 3: Showed up at the end


I'm done for now

Kiwi
Korr
Leaffan20
LSFIssue
Natalie
Rito
Shawn
Wikey

YOU'RE ALL NEXT!