I think we’re looking at Badger and one of Merc/Nav/outside chance of Josh

Next tier would be Badger and Vlady which feels less likely to me

Last tier would be Badger as Town and two of Merc/Nav/Josh


Leaning Badger and Merc or Nav with Vlady as SK

Merc/Nav/Josh who do you suspect the most between the other two?

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 9:04

Merc/Nav/Josh who do you suspect the most between the other two?

Probably Nav? Merc's posts haven't been great but he's doing better as the days go on. I don't really know what to make of Nav because he's slipping in and out of joke-y Nav which makes me go back and forth cause that usually only comes out when he's bored town. (srry meta)

And Nav's claim felt weirdly vague.

vladykins @ 9/7/2018 6:58

I correctly guessed mafia would go for me for being right about so many of them

This is the scummiest statement I've ever read. Many of us were right about mafia Brian, TIB, im317 - these votes were all pretty much slam dunks. The fact that you're pushing this is so bad - it just sounds like an excuse as to why you survived an attack.

Ahoda @ 9/7/2018 7:37

JJ @ 8/7/2018 21:20 Ahoda @ 8/7/2018 21:28 Vlady is the play today Josh is #2 Do you have reasons for Josh, Ahoda? I don't believe his claim at all. Seems a little too convenient his target happened to die D2. If I had his role I'm using it on someone like you or Curtis who gets a ton of activity early and often for other roles.

Oh. Josh 100% uses his role on his BFF imo.

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 7:45

What day did JJ claim tracker?

Day 2

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 7:47

But why SK would block me last night over you is absolutely beyond me

Yeah, me too. That's a big point against you.

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 6:04

Merc/Nav/Josh who do you suspect the most between the other two?

Merc more than Josh. But admittedly I have a hard time reading Josh as scum.

Josh @ 9/7/2018 6:36

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 9:04 Merc/Nav/Josh who do you suspect the most between the other two? Probably Nav? Merc's posts haven't been great but he's doing better as the days go on. I don't really know what to make of Nav because he's slipping in and out of joke-y Nav which makes me go back and forth cause that usually only comes out when he's bored town. (srry meta) And Nav's claim felt weirdly vague.

What more would you like me to clarify about my role. I have no active ability anymore in this game. I welcome Buffy to track me tonight if you have any doubt.

JJ @ 9/7/2018 10:09

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 7:47 But why SK would block me last night over you is absolutely beyond me Yeah, me too. That's a big point against you.

Against VLADY!

I don’t know why on earth he did it but it was clearly him (you’re right about it not being Jackie). I can’t exactly figure out why he would block me over you or especially Vlady but he most certainly did

Do you think SK’s suspicions against me all game were inauthentic?

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 10:20

JJ @ 9/7/2018 10:09 Curtis @ 9/7/2018 7:47 But why SK would block me last night over you is absolutely beyond me Yeah, me too. That's a big point against you. Against VLADY! I don’t know why on earth he did it but it was clearly him (you’re right about it not being Jackie). I can’t exactly figure out why he would block me over you or especially Vlady but he most certainly did Do you think SK’s suspicions against me all game were inauthentic?

I'm saying why would mafia block you? That's my point.

Exactly, I have no idea. But they did! Why would I have SK block me if I was scum with him? Why would he not block Vlady?

What does your tiered player list look like JJ

Curtis @ 9/7/2018 10:20

JJ @ 9/7/2018 10:09 Curtis @ 9/7/2018 7:47 But why SK would block me last night over you is absolutely beyond me Yeah, me too. That's a big point against you. Against VLADY! I don’t know why on earth he did it but it was clearly him (you’re right about it not being Jackie). I can’t exactly figure out why he would block me over you or especially Vlady but he most certainly did Do you think SK’s suspicions against me all game were inauthentic?

I was obviously town-reading him incorrectly all game and I remember when he latched onto BB's suspicions of me, I was surprised but just chalked it up to a different game, different environment, etc. So, no. I think as mafia he would have had to pick some town to get mis-lynched and you were someone he would want on that list. He just didn't know that's almost impossible. (:

I am leaning that you're town because of Ahoda. We have enough people left that I think it would be a risky move for you two to make such a ballsy move as scumbuddies... but then the more I say this the more I think you're very skilled at checking off your Mafia to do list and if you get town doc mis-lynched, kill me tonight, then who is left?

7 people:

Curt
Josh
Ahoda
Nav/Seb
Merc
Christian
Vladish
Badger
JJ

OR if Vlady is SK, then there are still probably at least two mafia left. Could be three, possibly.

That would mean only one more mis-lynch to go.

What do you think of mass claim today?

Also @ Josh. I think it's possible your claim is true and you're town but if you are, we really need you to step up and actually start scum-hunting so we win this. Nav too. I feel like Curtis is the only other person really scum-hunting and if he's mafia, we're screwed. So hope he's town.

Okay so tiered list:

Town:
JJ

Probably Town:
Curt
Ahoda

Leaning Town:
Christian

Unsure:
Josh
Nav/Seb
Merc

Scum:
Vladish
Badger


I think it makes sense that either Badger is scum and one of these three are also scum:

Josh
Nav/Seb
Merc


OR if Badger is just inactive town, than two are scum.

That's just working under the assumption there are two mafia left. I see Vlady as more of an SK possibility but he's still killing off town (also I forgot he's probably going to kill town tonight and there's another killer who could hit town so we're potentially at LYLO today).

I think we have to mass claim.