Okay I'm confused at two Town JOATs but I'll let it go for now.

Curtis @ 20/8/2017 23:17

im317 @ 20/8/2017 23:16 Curtis @ 20/8/2017 23:15 It seems I am 100% scum depending on the flip of about three different people Bring it on. Off with their heads given Mittens claim, if hes telling the truth then i think you are scum 95%. why tho?

because i thought his block on Dadd(i think, its all running together, but there being a block was the key) was you. if it really was Mittens then you are the least open about things.

I don't think either one claimed an alignment, so both being truthful means less than you might think.

Sneaky sumbitches. If rose is scum, I'll crap.

spindoctor02 @ 20/8/2017 23:23

THE GREAT DR @ 20/8/2017 22:21 JJ @ 20/8/2017 23:19 ROSE! Who is lying? Mittens or Zersch? You seemed to know for sure Mittens isn't GF? They are both being truthful. Rose, are you the universal mafia backup, and did you take over the role cop role after jamie died?

NAW NAW NAW

I'm using INTUITION and what I know. Both being truthful is a guess, but it's a guess i'd put more stake in than meta right now, and meta is the only thing that'd holding me back on it.

Everything points to Mittens being town, and truthful about his role. Everything points to Zersch being town, and truthful about his role. Either one would need a BIG ploy to actually be lying scum, and I don't see it happening.

I trust logic more than meta right now, since meta's been turning up some pretty shitty results so far.

I don't see it at all.

Rose as scum that is.

JJ @ 20/8/2017 21:24

Okay I'm confused at two Town JOATs but I'll let it go for now.

There were 2 town redirection type roles.

And several BPish roles

Primate @ 20/8/2017 22:30

Rose as scum that is.

I can see it. Would I put her as my #1 scum read? No, but would she be on the scum side of the list? Yep.

I give no credit for the shooting of Maddie. Maddie was going to die no matter what.

Unusual role distribution has a precedent in this game. Not saying one of zersch or mittens isn't full of shit.

spin did the think tank figure it out yet

I FEEL LIKE IT'S PRETTY OBVIOUS AT THIS POINT BUT I'M TRYING TO BE VAGUE ANYWAY

Primate @ 20/8/2017 22:32

Unusual role distribution has a precedent in this game. Not saying one of zersch or mittens isn't full of shit.

I believe this is the mods first game as hosts. I'm not sure you can read too much into role distribution.

THE GREAT DR @ 20/8/2017 22:33

spin did the think tank figure it out yet I FEEL LIKE IT'S PRETTY OBVIOUS AT THIS POINT BUT I'M TRYING TO BE VAGUE ANYWAY

No, I didn't figure it out. The others might have, but I hate reading novels on my phone.

alright this has gone on long enough i was the partner all along