Watch it Eben, you got Curtis on your tail!

Buffy @ 30/4/2016 16:56

Yeah it's a running joke that Bryce gets Tracker role.

ok gotcha

Brian, Wikey, Mal and Chris are people who are in the game but you can't really tell anything from their posts.

Bryce, who are your top suspicions and why?

jamie @ 30/4/2016 19:53

Eben - then goes to lynch an inactive Dadd - seemed to support Lamps' claim FC - lolz Vlady Buffy Bryce - already explained his reasoning earlier today Things that stuck out at me: ahoda just hopping around lynches, really wanting a vlady lynch

I still do.

Herm @ 30/4/2016 12:58

*likelier

more likely :P

Herm @ 30/4/2016 17:14

Bryce, who are your top suspicions and why?

We don't have TOO much to look into, just mainly people's reactions to the Lamps lynch. So all my reads are VERY tentative.

Looking back on Day 2, Ahoda mentioned early on that "I don't see how Lamps is scum because there is no way SK or Mafia attacked JC"

When Lamps came in he said that JC was a likely Vig or SK kill, not a scum kill.

Curtis then hopped on board by saying he agreed with Ahoda that Lamps was a more likely scum kill attempt and that JC was a vig kill.

Dadd then hopped on board the train to lynch Eben over Lamps, and mentioned that JC was a likely Vig kill

Redster hopped on board the Eben lynch over Lamps, saying he agreed with Ahoda/Curtis/Dadd, and calling Me/Eben/Merc out for being so deadset against Lamps from the start.

Timmah made a good point on page 7 that usually in most games, when someone survives an attack, 90% of the time they're scum and most people are on board with lynching that person, but in this game like four people started defending Lamps hardcore.

Herm looks good by consistently pushing Lamps to claim.

Ahoda jumped back in after Timmah to state again that he didn't think scum would ever kill JC night 1

Dadd then hopped in to agree, speculated about whether it was a Vig or an SK, mentioned that he could see a SK killing JC

Then an argument happened between Vlady vs Ahoda/Dadd with Vlady being pretty adamant that Lamps was obvi mafia and Ahoda/Dadd defending Lamps.

(note that at this point Dadd had a lynch vote on Lamps tho)

Rose came across kind of scummy on page 9 by hopping in and kind of weighing both sides without making a final call.

---- okay so that's only the first ten pages, I can get caught up on the rest tomorrow, but even those first ten pages told me quit a bit ----

My biggest reads for scum are Curtis/Ahoda/Dadd/Redster, they were the one's who were primarily pushing that "JC was NOT killed by scum" narrative earlier on. However, would scum really be that stupid to go so gung-ho defending their godfather who survived a night attack and didn't even had a claim ready?

My biggest reads for town are Angi, Timmah, herm, Eben, Vlady

*prepares for onslaught of backlash*

THIS IS ALL BASED OFF OF THE FIRST TEN PAGES OF DAY 2. I don't feel confident enough in any of my reads yet to legitimately go after someone based off of the fact that they had a wrong read, because lord knows I'm guilty of that, (remember when I almost flipped the vote to lynch an inactive town vanilla over the mafia godfather in ATTWS when I was town? I can't criticize anyone for being wrong on a read). Which is why I lean towards lynching a less active player this time around.

Bryce

My biggest reads for scum are Curtis/Ahoda/Dadd/Redster, they were the one's who were primarily pushing that "JC was NOT killed by scum" narrative earlier on. However, would scum really be that stupid to go so gung-ho defending their godfather who survived a night attack and didn't even had a claim ready?

Well, we know FC flipped Mafia and he didn't exactly defend or attack Lamps.

I bet scum's in that same category. This is why I was originally suspicious of Rose. Rose and Curtis both lynched FC on Day 1, however.

Per your observations, scum probably didn't push Lamps for a claim but were probably more likely to just lynch him.

Day 3 Vote Count

Herm (2/12) - Badger, Angi
Wikey (2/12) - Ari, Dadd
vlady (1/12) - Canuck
thisisbad (1/12) - Ahoda
Rose (0/12) - Herm
Bryce (0/12) - Curtis, Buffy
Badger (0/12) - Bryce

*Deadline is 12pm est on Sunday (tomorrow) to try to get us away from the late starts/finishes.

Herm @ 30/4/2016 18:22

Per your observations, scum probably didn't push Lamps for a claim but were probably more likely to just lynch him.

This is a good insight. I did want to point out who was pushing the "JC couldn't have been killed by scum" narrative though, because I didn't think that argument made much sense. I think a majority of scum didn't really push too hard for a Lamps claim or lynch, but didn't defend him too much either. I think it's worth it to make note of who WAS defending him though, although I agree it's not enough to lynch someone for without any more evidence.

I don't think Herm is a good lynch choice.

Why are people lynching Wikey again? I don't remember seeing him post so I'm going to go ahead and ##Lynch Wikey because as I've stated a few different times, I'm leaning towards a more less-active lynch for today since it's pretty slow-moving without a ton of information.

I havent read anything that has happened today.

##lynch Bryce

It's actually possible that Rose could still be scum since she was the first lynch vote on FC, it wasn't until Curtis added a second lynch that he got in danger.

But we'll reserve that for another day.

Angi @ 30/4/2016 10:27

Nofo of December 2015 @ 29/4/2016 21:59 I am the most clear here so fuck you mafia You meant Angi right ;)

If I had to pick a chick.

##Lynch Herm