I really don't think he is lying about his role. It is very believable.

Buffy @ 17/4/2014 22:00

Herm @ 17/4/2014 14:52 Ah, the part about the flavor was a joke lol. Ah well, it's been said I can't take a joke. I guess this is further evidence. :P

I don't always understand sarcasm and can be naive and gullible. I'm just as bad lol. :)

Shawn @ 17/4/2014 20:04

I really don't think he is lying about his role. It is very believable.

Doesn't mean he's telling the truth. I don't believe herm's claim either. He can also help the town by hiding behind drrr since she's bulletproof and also a big suspect.

Ahoda @ 17/4/2014 14:51

Tricks @ 17/4/2014 19:44 Ahoda @ 17/4/2014 13:31 Well he should tell. It clears someone if he dies and shows up town. He should hide behind drr to see if she's town tbh. No. Boc should not reveal his target. I think he should. It doesn't matter since scum knows who's scum. If he dies it clears someone and if his target flips scum and he's alive he's scum too. I don't see any reason not to out who he's hiding behind.

Yes, scum knows who is scum, but if he tells us he's going to hide behind someone and then scum wants to kill two people at once, then they'll know who to go for.

If he's hiding behind someone who isn't on anyone suspect list, then we don't need to know who that person is.

Well, I was mostly skeptical because it feels like if he just hid behind a bulletproof he could stay there and eat chips and relax lol. But if it's a real role it's a real role. I just wonder how that whole hiding behind a bulletproof person works though. If Boc had been smart, he would've hid behind Rose.

Buffy @ 17/4/2014 15:03

Herm @ 17/4/2014 15:01 One of the reasons I think Boc made up this role is because Boc could just hide behind Rose/someone bulletproof and he'd never ever die. Has this role shown up before? I'm very skeptic about this role because it has such a big loophole. Yes it's a real role.

Does the person he hides behind get told that he's hiding there?

Angi @ 17/4/2014 20:13

Buffy @ 17/4/2014 15:03 Herm @ 17/4/2014 15:01 One of the reasons I think Boc made up this role is because Boc could just hide behind Rose/someone bulletproof and he'd never ever die. Has this role shown up before? I'm very skeptic about this role because it has such a big loophole. Yes it's a real role. Does the person he hides behind get told that he's hiding there?

No

Herm @ 17/4/2014 15:11

If Boc had been smart, he would've hid behind Rose.

This is not true because it is still very possible rose is scum

Angi @ 17/4/2014 20:10

Ahoda @ 17/4/2014 14:51 Tricks @ 17/4/2014 19:44 Ahoda @ 17/4/2014 13:31 Well he should tell. It clears someone if he dies and shows up town. He should hide behind drr to see if she's town tbh. No. Boc should not reveal his target. I think he should. It doesn't matter since scum knows who's scum. If he dies it clears someone and if his target flips scum and he's alive he's scum too. I don't see any reason not to out who he's hiding behind. Yes, scum knows who is scum, but if he tells us he's going to hide behind someone and then scum wants to kill two people at once, then they'll know who to go for. If he's hiding behind someone who isn't on anyone suspect list, then we don't need to know who that person is.

I didn't say post who's he going to hide behind each night. But he said he's been hiding behind the same person it will narrow suspect list down and he could use his role to test drrr since she's on everyone's suspect list. I'd gladly sub a hider for scum lynch any day of the week.

Okay, I have a few primary suspicions at the moment, so here's the rundown.

drrr
A lot of posting with very little actual scumhunting. On Day 1, she hopped the Jordan wagon early. On Day 2, she hopped the Malion wagon rather late. I strongly believe she and Brian were distancing on Day 3. Brian's accusations were easy to defend against and she wasn't really considered a viable lynch target anyway. Drrr threw a lot of suspicion at Brian without an actual vote... And then, when the Vernon wagon started, she hopped on without much of an explanation besides quoting Vernon's weird post. She has been on all three townie lynches with fairly opportunistic timing.

g0
VERY sparse posting with little content when he does. Vernon wanted to lynch g0 on Day 2 and g0 OMGUSed without actually voting. Didn't exist on Day 3. OMGUSing Boc today.

Angi
Consistently active lurking - posting without content, commenting on current happenings, a couple bandwagon votes, started a wagon on Curtis with stupid reasoning, inconsistent town reads. Started the Greenday wagon then never returned.

I expected to have Shawn on this list, but I actually ended up with a good defense of him?
Shawn
Low activity. Didn't really have a clue what was going on Day 3 before posting with a sudden Greenday vote, then said he'd need to look into Herm/Brian suspicions because he didn't understand them, and never followed up. Did, however, suggest going after someone voting for Curtis on Day 2, which earns some brownie points given that Hot Cocoa was on that wagon. The Greenday suspicion was established on Day 2, so it didn't really come out of nowhere.

While I think drrr looks the worst, I think having Boc hide behind her is actually a fairly sound plan if he agrees to it, and I'd like to give g0 the chance to participate more.

##lynch Angi

Shawn @ 17/4/2014 20:16

Herm @ 17/4/2014 15:11 If Boc had been smart, he would've hid behind Rose. This is not true because it is still very possible rose is scum

And he can use his role to find out.

Wait, tricks agrees with me.

*insert shocked face. Jpg *

Shawn @ 17/4/2014 22:16

Herm @ 17/4/2014 15:11 If Boc had been smart, he would've hid behind Rose. This is not true because it is still very possible rose is scum

I see what you guys say now, I re-read his roleclaim and he said if he chose scum he'd die. I just assumed he could hide behind scum as well.

## unlynch

Tricks @ 17/4/2014 15:17

Angi Consistently active lurking - posting without content, commenting on current happenings, a couple bandwagon votes, started a wagon on Curtis with stupid reasoning, inconsistent town reads. Started the Greenday wagon then never returned.

The site was down after my vote on Greenday, and my reason for the lynch on Curtis was NOT stupid. Just because he was a stupid townie doesn't make the lynch votes on him stupid. Only one bandwagon vote and never lurking thank you very much. :P At least get your facts straight. And to meta game, my town reads are ALWAYS horrible :P

And have any of you even lynched mafia yet? Because my votes on town are no more suspicious then you all lynching town. Just saying.