Dutchiee might be the lyncher. He's been going after Matt since day one for what appears to be an innocent mistake. I really don't see any evidence for going so hard against Matt.

That's the point he is going after Matt for silly evidence. That meanes he probably got something out of his role that told him Matt was scum or something or else he would have dropped what Matt did on day 1

Nofo @ 11/8/2013 12:41

Dutchiee might be the lyncher. He's been going after Matt since day one for what appears to be an innocent mistake. I really don't see any evidence for going so hard against Matt.

Unless he's so very sure in his gut, he could've visited Matt N1 if he has a role that allows him to do so. Makes sense that Dutchiee would visit him since he was very suspicious of him. It kinda makes me think that Dutchiee might've learned something, but I'd have to check his D3 posts again to figure out how he pushed for Matt with the (potential) info he had

Shawn @ 11/8/2013 12:43

That's the point he is going after Matt for silly evidence. That meanes he probably got something out of his role that told him Matt was scum or something or else he would have dropped what Matt did on day 1

Has he come out and said that? No. Therefore it's idiotic to assume he got anything.

It isn't idiotic. I did the same thig last game with Henry. It would be idiotic for him to still be suspicious of Matt from day 1

To be fair it's just as idiotic to assume that Dutchiee is 'The Lyncher' just because he has been consistently lynching someone (:

Curtis @ 11/8/2013 12:46

To be fair it's just as idiotic to assume that Dutchiee is 'The Lyncher' just because he has been consistently lynching someone (:

How is that when most (if not all) of his posts namedrop Matt with minimal evidence on Day 3 at least?

I was thinking just now that if Matt was silenced, this would be a time the Mafia would try to push for him to get out. Like Nofo said, that kinda points to Dutchiee. Then Dylan joined. But then DD joined the train right after, just adding that Matt was fishy


SO, I looked back

DD @ 9/8/2013 1:12

Alright you guys... I feel really badly about this but I am just going to vote. I would rather take out an inactive, because I don't think we have substantial evidence to lynch JJ. I don't have a good reason to lynch anyone else either. ##lynch: im317 Gotta get to bed, sorry.

She was the sole lynch vote on 317 the day he was silenced. In a day with tons of finger pointing, she wanted to go for an inactive and conveniently chose the one who was inactive due to not being able to speak. Why not go for Soccer who hasn't been on the board in days over 317?

##Lynch DD

Seems like way too much of a coincidence to me. The silencer is obviously scum so the rest of the scum will know who's silenced each day

Nofo @ 11/8/2013 12:49

Curtis @ 11/8/2013 12:46 To be fair it's just as idiotic to assume that Dutchiee is 'The Lyncher' just because he has been consistently lynching someone (: How is that when most (if not all) of his posts namedrop Matt with minimal evidence on Day 3 at least?

I'm not saying it's unlikely, I'm saying it's really just as likely as Dutchiee having actual proof. There's no way of knowing either way unless Dutchiee sheds some light

Just like to point out that I also knew jj was town. If it's not clear that's because she was hiding behind me

Well if Dutchie was suspicious of Matt and had a useful role he could of used it on Matt thus confirming his suspicions.

Mal (0/10) Shawn
Shawn (2/10) Bryce, Nofo
Jeff (1/10) Henry
Matt (1/10) Dylan, DD
DD (1/10) Curtis

4 hours

lynch: patrick

same reason as yesterday

Why don't Shawn/Dylan/Dutchiee's lynch votes count?