One mafia left after Stargate is lynched imo.

Unaligned already wins with whoever wins so why would an unaligned have an ability that just reduces the options of winning? Lol

Even if that wasn't problematic, why would you be BP at night and can trigger this ability at any point during the day? Sounds like an OP role. You can just join the side that's about to win right before your lynch

Penner @ 9/10/2021 16:04

Stargate @ 9/10/2021 17:03 I am not wrong in saying that mafia win if two are left right now and I get lynched. It's also very very very possible there is only 1 mafioso left, in which case lynching me doesn't change much. When I came forward with my role info and two scum didn't come forward to get my to join and win with them, my assumption was there's only 1 mafia left otherwise why pass up an insta-win. But Lamps makes a fair point. If they can win by lynching me, then they didn't need to come forward and have me join them. They just need to have me get lynched. That being said, I mean, it's possible there's just the 1 mafia member left. I'm not saying that's not possible, I'm just saying it's possible 2 mafia are left, and in that case I don't want to lose with town now that I've joined town. You will win if town wins even if you die lol

Penner, if there's 2 mafia left and I die, town loses.

5 left after I die. They kill tonight. 4 left. 2 of them 2 of town. They tie it. They kill again at night. Even if Curtis is alive to kill at that point to prolong the game, mafia and town get off kills, 2 people left. It ties again, mafia kills at night and wins.

If you're town and you roll your dice for no vote, mafia would then win at f4, too.

Best case, there's just 1 mafia left and we win as town. But I am now town. pinky swear.

Lamps @ 9/10/2021 17:04

Ahoda and I are both town I think... I expect to take the lynch tomorrow but best to start thinking of alternatives already.

Lamps @ 9/10/2021 17:05

One mafia left after Stargate is lynched imo.

Who would be mafia then? Me and curt are pretty much confirmed and Penner has confirmed his bastard role. I genuinely don't understand how you could possibly trust Ahoda from your point of view.

To be clear I think Ahoda is town too and lamp is scum but lamps line of thinking doesn't add up

Rodney @ 9/10/2021 16:06

Unaligned already wins with whoever wins so why would an unaligned have an ability that just reduces the options of winning? Lol Even if that wasn't problematic, why would you be BP at night and can trigger this ability at any point during the day? Sounds like an OP role. You can just join the side that's about to win right before your lynch

I had no win condition and could only win with whatever faction I joined. Only then did I get a win condition.

You can do the thinking Rod, I pass.

I'll be lynched tomorrow so I don't have to do any thinking for what to do afterwards.

Lamps, if there is just one mafioso left and it's you, I'mma be sads. If you hadn't voted for me, I wouldn't have felt pressure to join town in the hopes of winning with them whether I got lynched or not. And I could've considered more jumping blinding into being a Pakistani. At which point all we would've had to have done was get someone else voted out and then we could've done all the stuff I've laid out for how mafia just wins if there's two left right now and a town gets lynched!!

I’m town Starry 🤷🏽‍♀️

Lamps @ 9/10/2021 17:04

Ahoda and I are both town I think... I expect to take the lynch tomorrow but best to start thinking of alternatives already.

Penner is making big brain town moves by making town lose

I’d be shocked if there were three town vanillas and a mafia roleblocker. Seems like a weak role to give a likely three-person team

The sad part is that Ahoda likes to scum-side so my fingers are crossed I roll a 3 tonight (and don’t die) in case he plays against his alleged town wincon

The graveyard can sleep peacefully at night knowing the A-team is on the case

We should be discussing who could be Pakistani and how. Past votes, past comments, past susses they've had. Things Vern and 317 said, etc.

Penner @ 9/10/2021 17:39

The sad part is that Ahoda likes to scum-side so my fingers are crossed I roll a 3 tonight (and don’t die) in case he plays against his alleged town wincon

If I was doing that I would be voting lamps