HOF
- Primate's foreskin incident. I intentionally made that role hoping that person would be greedy and take it for themselves hoping it'd give them some huge power, and SURE ENOUGH! Classic moment

- Rose actually getting the cape and getting to use it. Of all the roles that was the one I was probably most hoping would come into play, but I did gate it behind 3+ nights of actions for a reason since its game implications are kinda crazy. Even then I was surprised how "easy" it was for her to convince people when she easily could've been scum trying to deceive their way to extra power. The only thing I wish would've come out of that role that didn't was if she dragged some scum to the woods. That would've been a bit more interesting dig decision. But IN ANY CASE, what came out of the rewind was pretty interesting, especially the fact that JJ's role was now in the open and everyone KNEW who she'd be tracking on a given night from her likes. That was an interesting twist to her role that I definitely didn't predict

- Nav's leadership. Honestly, not to take too much away from his teammates (who all pulled their own...for the most part (: ), he was what held that team together. He had a few hiccups, but was mostly pretty solid with his decisions, especially on Night 6 where he narrowly avoided disaster but ended up achieving the optimal outcome. If he would've targeted Merc with his own action instead the town very well might've won
-- sidenote: I'm aware that giving two kills to the mafia was kinda crazy, BUT I did kinda expect he'd use his protect once or twice which didn't end up happening. Even still, this was faaar from the reason the mafia won/the town lost

- Curtis somehow arguing his way out of the fact that JJ saw him visit Rose the night she died. I mean, he didn't actually kill her but still, I couldn't believe the town dropped that point that easily

- The second half town (primarily JJ, Rose, Jackie, and Christian) almost pulled out the win for them after a disastrous start. Worth noting: Jackie's mimic action on Night 5: Part 2 was to copy Badger's action and use it on Josh, which would've killed him AND all but revealed that Badger has a killing role. That would've been a huge game-changing moment if she hadn't been targeted/if Vlady would've protected her

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

HOL
- the Igor SK team did a good job surviving but...half their kill choices were pretty IFFY! Especially their overlaps with the mafia on both Night 5s. Partially bad luck, but there were 'safer' targets out there that had less of a chance of conflicting

- me for fucking up and killing Jamie a night early!! :) whoops

- Zersch's cult for never getting off the ground. Honestly wasn't much of his fault (maybe he could've started recruiting earlier but meh) but man, I wanted to see that cult be a factor

- The auto-lynch on Henry :(

- Even though I can sort of applaud him getting revenge for Henry...Wikey's lynch on Zach was pretty awful for the town. Easily one of their biggest power roles taken out for no reason. NOT ONLY THAT, but this led to the D3 lynch getting wasted on Wikey cuz he seemed like such obvious scum. This left the town with a VERY small margin of error for the rest of the game - 9/16 of their members had been taken out by the time Wikey's reign of fuckery was over and they could re-focus

- The Vlady lynch. Town definitely picked it up in the second half of the game and had a good shot of winning, but they fumbled it big time by taking out their doc. If they would've killed Nav instead, it would've been almost a slam dunk win for them

- ...THAT SAID! Vlady had some pretty unfortunate targets, which did contribute to his ultimate demise. The only person he ended up successfully saving was himself, even though he had the benefit of a redo on Night 5

So, not to whine because town did suck, esp with the Vlady lynch but... two kills each night for mafia was definitely a big factor in their win. I would never have chosen not to have two kills each night if I were mafia. I think it should have had some limitations.

I probably should've forced it to alternate yeah

When I read the role I thought it was going to be an RNG every night to fit the Two Face coin theme

Two Seb @ 11/7/2018 0:47

When I read the role I thought it was going to be an RNG every night to fit the Two Face coin theme

this was actually my initial thought when I was coming up with the role but I hate using RNG in mafia so decided against it (:

Whats RNG?

Random?

JJ @ 10/7/2018 22:51

Whats RNG?

Random Number Generator

JJ @ 10/7/2018 22:51

Whats RNG?

Random number generator.

Though in this case it would be more of a coin flip.

I love playing Two Face.

You are two-faced lol. But I like your rank.

HOL

- Boc for never turning flood control off of our forum!!!!!

To be fair, it was v difficult to avoid doubling up with the mafia’s kill targets on N5’s with so few players left to choose from and the mafia getting to kill two of them :$

oh

I'm never voting during D1 again :]

JJ @ 11/7/2018 0:43

So, not to whine because town did suck, esp with the Vlady lynch but... two kills each night for mafia was definitely a big factor in their win. I would never have chosen not to have two kills each night if I were mafia. I think it should have had some limitations.

I've always wanted to try this so I appreciate Boc doing it. It was interesting to see. I have had use a mafia assassin where he didn't know who the mafia was and wasn't part of their forum but won with them and he could kill each night. I was OP but town had so many fails and missteps it probably makes it seem more OP then it was. Josh's and Navs claims were really bad and not sure why anyone believed them.