HALL OF FAME

- JJ/Buffy. She hated her role and had no qualms letting us know. Putting that to the side, she fulfilled her win condition as an outed third party. Even though she was of no danger to the Town as she was, it was still fun to see a third party role get the Town to assist them in fulfilling their wincon - by handing the doll back to her and giving her control of her own destiny once more. Her reads were also very much on point, and she was one of the people who offered a list of three scum, one town the day of Ben's fatal fourway.

- Lamps. Another person with solid reads that offered up a 3/4 scum list for Ben. Even if he had terrible reads he would be here for "fuck your egg" alone. Also his final stretch of Vig kills were on point.

- Jamie. For rhyming like a champion instead of just posting once or twice, trying to explain what happened, and then waiting until the next day to participate. Also his Ghoul redirect of Sock, causing Sock to kill and janitor himself was hilarious and an unintentional masterstroke.

- Nav/Seb. Seemed to be pretty keen on Chris being the Arsonist for a while, but he's mainly here because we as hosts really enjoyed seeing someone with actual knowledge of the subject matter getting into the game. Him analyzing and trying to figure out characters and whether or not the roles made sense attached to them was fun to watch. And in an alternate dimension where Town found themselves in trouble at any point, his knowledge could have been a life saver.

- Ben. This was one of the few (the only?) roles I contributed to the game, so I loved that my little Teddy Long did a great job with it. He could very easily have given scum a lazy day to do whatever they wanted without having to worry too much about where to put their votes if he'd selected four town.

- Zach. Only made one successful save, and that was because of the lightning rod, but still. He had a very important role with a handicap to it that should have called attention to him each day, but it never really amounted to anything.

- TIB. When he was last scum standing, he was entertaining on the Mafia forum.

- Rose/Drr. Her passion for being Big Boss Man was inspirational.

- Brian. Getting into character as Lana - hot.

- Christian. Did all of the heavy lifting. Sweet boy, great host.

- DS. Played a perfect game, really. And was the saving grace of the Masons. Carried Patrick on his back.

HALL OF LAME

- Curtis. Dying N1 again. How about you settle down and quit dying N1 so often.

- Masons. The forum was super boring, but I don't blame that one on him; I'm sure he would have been more than happy to talk had Patrick had more (read: anything at all) to say.

- Ahoda. Unlike Jamie, really didn't do anything or have any fun with his stipulation of having to argue with JJ on D2. Did make one mean comment but that was it. I guess we should have added dire stipulations if they didn't do what they were told.

- The Mafia team as a whole. To be completely honest if I had seen the distribution prior to Christian sending out roles I would have been the first (?) host to say "nah, we're re-rolling that shit" and pushed for him to randomize the roles a second time.

- Tim. We're sorry to even have to mention his name again. Him pretending to be an idiot (was he pretending tho) seemed to work on some of you, but shit. He had some of the worst timing with his votes that I've ever seen. Everything he did screamed scum. Claiming Gobbledy Gooker was a hilarious move but also horrible.

- J$. His fake claim was terrible. I don't even remember what it was, but Christian has this on the list and I agree with him.

- Jake. He had one job. He had three people to get lynched. It was all he had to worry about, and he just sat back and let Tim get lynched without being a part of it.

- Free Candy. Firing off his poison kill N1 without much thought put into it cost Town a great role, and a great Big Boss Man.

- Hosts. For neither of us noticing we left out the "can't roleblock the same person back to back nights" stipulation on the Mafia Roleblocker. Though given how everything went, they needed it.

- The other guy. Could and should have helped his friend more than he did, not a sweet boy.

List based on what Christian had PM'd me + things I remembered happening by looking at the Night Actions topic.

Christian can edit to add more if he has new ones in mind.

dam :(

Curtis @ 22/11/2017 7:21

dam :(

:rofl:

So was Jamie scum?

Zersch, you're on the Hall of Fame. Don't be a silly goose.

I would also put Ahoda on the Hall of Fame. He did give Spin extra use of his role, which would have been beneficial had he not been blocked, or redirected to Jamie. And also gave Dadd and Lamps each an extra kill as well.

I'm happy being somewhere in the middle this game. My investigations were terrible choices, but my reads in-game were pretty good, so I'm glad I could help town a little bit to the victory.

Thanks again for the game Zersch and the other guy. Wait, I think I screwed that up.

Zersch, I asked Christian if my 1 post met the requirement and he said yes btw.

Christian @ 22/11/2017 12:13

I would also put Ahoda on the Hall of Fame. He did give Spin extra use of his role, which would have been beneficial had he not been blocked, or redirected to Jamie. And also gave Dadd and Lamps each an extra kill as well.

No I deserved HOL for sure, but not for the reason Zersch listed. lol

Spin @ 22/11/2017 12:17

I'm happy being somewhere in the middle this game. My investigations were terrible choices, but my reads in-game were pretty good, so I'm glad I could help town a little bit to the victory. Thanks again for the game Zersch and the other guy. Wait, I think I screwed that up.

Sheesh, same here ... just not being Hall of Lame is a win for me.

thanks for hosting you two, fun game

HOL?
I'd do the same thing again based on D1.
But hey, if you have an unknown vote on you early, you must be scum. :thumbsup:

thats really not what happened but okay

Ahoda @ 22/11/2017 13:19

Zersch, I asked Christian if my 1 post met the requirement and he said yes btw.

Yeah, but that's just lazy lol. You could've had so much more fun with that. I think you should've been mod-killed. :P