HOF

- Nofo! Off the heels of winning Worst Mafia Player, Nofo killed it in this game. Literally. I was really worried when he got vigilante thinking he'd just kill people for lulzies, but he was incredibly accurate with his kills and was subtle enough in the daytime to where scum laid off him. Nobody expected Nofo to be vig at all, at least not on the scum teams. The town would have lost without his kills, plain and simple. Nofo handed the game to the town on a red satin pillow.

- Chris25 for getting, what I believe to be, the first Lyncher win of our mafia games to date. Played well. Didn't come off too obvious or strong by not getting obvious tunnel vision or anything. Although he did have it easy getting scum as his target (the two lyncher cards had top and bottom variations depending on the sign-up sheet, Dylan was next to Chris so that is why he was his target), there's many ways it could have been fucked up too.

- Was pretty impressed with Schrauben on the mafia forum. Very perceptive and was a good leader for the team. Big step up from Billy Hill at the very least! His death caused a domino effect for the team.

- JJ for immediately noticing the Psychotrooper role and not claiming like all the other cops did. JJ in general was a great town force to contrast her useless role (as cult did not exist) and all scum factions were pretty frightened of her. Alien used their one and only kill for this reason.

- Kat going for interesting over practical by picking Town Black Goo even though it was a ridiculous role to choose. Just wish she would have been more active to increase the odds of her actually being visited! Would have been fun to see this come into action but at least it created some paranoia anyway.

- The three main cops dying the same night the Psychotrooper did was hilarious.

- Curtis killing Angi the same night she investigated him. Then killing Greenday the same night he tracked him. Curt in general had a great run and was sadly killed for being too town by the mafia, who were terrified of him.

- Night 5, a night of silliness that gave the town the edge they needed. The mafia used up their strongman kill on an unkillable Curtis Page, Christian gets caught by Matt while failing to kill Werewolf Hunter Paul and Nofo hits the mafia where it hurts by taking out their defacto leader in Schrauben.

- Paul's soft claim, which was a great way to rile up the werewolves enough to attack him. He should also obviously get credit for correctly choosing Patrick over Samm on the final day.

HOL

- The massive amount of claims on DAY TWO! I understand some of the cops got bad reads and some of them were necessary to figure out that Psychotrooper existed, but the others were incredibly unnecessary.

- Nofo's only misfire of the entire game by killing Ari could have potentially been a disastrous mistake. Ari would have successfully protected Wikey that night, which would have saved two townies from death.

- Mafia's Night 7. Jeffrey was actually the one scum who was afraid of Nofo being an important role and he was right! They had a chance to kill or block Nofo and instead did neither. DD killed vanilla Vic and Jeff roleblocked a passive Paul. Jeffrey would die that night and pretty much seal the mafia's fate.

- The aliens! Ouch. Total wipe out. I was actually rooting for them when the game started so seeing them get picked off before either the Werewolves or Mafia were even known to anyone was shocking.

- Werewolves fumbling at the goaline and attempting to kill Paul over Matt - who had just claimed Seer! Matt would hit Christian that same night and Christian would fail to come up with a claim, sealing the werewolves fate entirely.

- Boc's terrible backtracking on Matt was cringeworthy.

- Moose's lynch. Why?

- Ahoda claiming on Day 4 after the mass cop genocide to clear Samm of all people. This was beyond silly. Also his totally wrong assumption that there HAD to be at least one of every faction because he could investigate them all as Cop-of-all-trades. He had both scum groups wanting him gone immediately after that before he could ever get any useful information from his incredibly useful role.

- Lamps. Tunnel vision on Wikey and then the temper tantrum on Day 4 when nobody wanted to do it. Baiting Vic to kill him was really head scratching. I guess he thought Vic was scum and wanted him to go down with him but he only did if he was LYNCHED, not shot! Either way, very nonsensical actions.

- Vic for actually following through on killing Lamps. Yes he was a distraction but it was clearly obvious Lamps was soft-claiming bomb and wanted Vic to go down with him.

- Mafia on Night 3 for contemplating killing Rob for being a cop (outed WEREWOLF HUNTER at this point!) and then not submitting a kill at all!

- Rob investigating Curtis twice and then investigating.... himself! I have no clue what he was trying to do here.

Night 1

Nofo kills Herm DD kills Brian Patrick kills Kathleen Christian watches Curtis Jeff tracks Herm Schrauben roleblocks Dylan Shadow mafia investigates Christian Angi SK investigates Patrick Matt Werewolf investigates Jeff Rob Werewolf investigates Curtis Boc watches Ari JJ cult investigates Ari Greenday tracks Wikey Ari protects Ari

Night 2

DD kills Korr Patrick kills Shadow Nofo kills Kiwi JJ cult investigates Curtis Angi SK investigates Dylan Dylan roleblocks/investigates Kiwi Ari protects Angi Shadow mafia investigates Lamps Greenday tracks Kiwi Matt werewolf investigates Ahoda Rob werewolf investigates Curtis Christian watches JJ Schrauben roleblocks Ahoda Jeff tracks Curtis

Night 3

Ari protects Ari Greenday tracks Angi Angi SK investigates Curtis Ahoda alien investigates Samm Rob scans himself Curtis kills Angi JJ cult investigates Dylan Nofo kills Tony Dylan kills JJ Dylan roleblocks DD Jeff tracks Ahoda Christian kills Rob Christian watches Rob Schrauben roleblocks Wikey DD kills Rob (Blocked)

Night 4

Ari protects Wikey DD kills Wikey Nofo kills Ari Patrick kills Ahoda Ahoda investigates Christan Curtis kills Greenday Greenday tracks Curtis Christian watches Curtis Jeff tracks Ari Schrauben roleblocks Ahoda

Night 5

DD strongman kills Curtis Patrick kills Paul (fails) Curtis kills Paul (Blocked) Nofo kills Schrauben Schrauben roleblocks Patrick (Blocked) Christian watches Matt Matt werewolf investigates Christian

Night 6

DD kills Vic Jeff tracks Paul Patrick kills Matt Nofo kills Jeff Matt werewolf investigates Patrick

Night 7

DD kills Nofo Patrick kills Nofo Nofo kills Patrick

Night 8

Patrick kills Jamie

Question! Were we able to use our strongman kill and our factional kill (so 2 kills) on the same night? or does the strongman kill replace the factional kill/make it invincible?

Strongman takes up the factional kill

FUCK YOUR STRONGMAN KILL

oh well

I scanned myself because I had a Vernon moment and didn't read the role descriptions, so I figured Psychotrooper was the same as a bus driver role. When someone told me what it actually did, I figured the simplest way to see whether there was a Psychotrooper or not (since I was in the States and didn't have time to read thirty-odd pages was to scan the only person I knew wasn't a werewolf (myself) and see what came up.

In retrospect I probably should have done something less stupid.

I was so worried that I was going to be lynched day 1 for lulz or because I gave up the Jailkeeper role. (I seriously got two awesome roles and I hated it. So glad nobody ever pressed on it.)

Patrick was so obvious scum in that final day... "hmmm....I'll wait for more info before I lynch."

The first time "Curtis" and "too town" were put together ever

Honestly, I wasn't even trying to get lynched // none of that had to do with my role. I was trying to get shot though, and I knew Vic wouldn't die if he shot me. Wasted 2 town roles oops :p

I'm gonna try more in the future. I had fun actually helping town and not fucking around.

I knew I was HOL this time for opting to try to kill Paul instead of Matt. I thought they were both Seers, one Town, one Mafia. I thought I had it figured it out. Once Paul flipped Town Seer, we'd be able to get Matt lynched. It was a gamble that did not pay off.

Samm @ 28/1/2015 16:48

The first time "Curtis" and "too town" were put together ever

I got unnecessary heat every day and kept surviving, but was eventually taken out by mafia for being "most confirmed town". lel

Did anyone think that when I was first in the Hall of Lame for ATTWS that I would one day be first in the Hall of Fame?

I sure as hell didn't.

I just want my christmas epilogue. I'll never win again.